Opinion: seven reasons the 997 is the best generation of Porsche 911

We’ve had 51 years of brilliant 911s leaving the Werk II factory at Zuffenhausen, but which generation is the greatest? Many say it is the 993 as the pinnacle of automotive engineering with air cooling. Others say it is now the 964 (marking some turnaround from only five years ago. Where did all those oil leaks disappear to, I wonder?).

Then there’s the school of thought that suggests the pre-impact bumper era should rightfully be lavished with the crown due to the sheer purity offered by these wholly mechanical classics. Of course, there is a case for every 911 generation as the greatest, but I have difficulty in looking past the 997. Here’s why:

1) It represented a return to form after the 996
I’ve said before that we should forever be grateful to the 996 as the saviour of Porsche, but the reality is it’s still the marmite era of the entire 911 spectrum. The M96 engine is far from bulletproof (IMS, RMS, and scored bore horror stories should suitably confirm that one) and those runny-egg headlamps were a kick in the stomach for those who had long admired the simple, elegant vista of every single 911 pre-1998. Then there’s the 996’s interior, which fell short of Porsche’s usual high standards of luxury and opulence as cost-cutting became the new buzzword.

However, the 997 brought a much-needed return to traditional 911 aesthetics – admittedly through borrowing styling cues from the 993 – without the bulbous evolution of the longer and heavier 991s. The interior was completely overhauled with luxury once again in mind, too. Even better, 997 interiors have stood the test of time since, unlike the dated 996.

Engines also improved for the 997: despite suspect revelations about the early M97, it doesn’t suffer from the same reputation as the M96, while the DFI engines fitted to Gen2 997s are considered bullet-proof.
Make no mistake, the 997’s role should not be underestimated: if the 996 saved Porsche, the 997 saved the legacy of the 911 as we know it.

2) It’s the last bastion of the mechanical 911
Sure, the 997 was bestowed with an entire catalogue of electronic driving aids such as PASM, VTG, PTM and PSM to name a few, but the takeover of the ECU only intensified under the subsequent 991. Most significantly, electric steering in all 991s plus PDK-only transmission and rear axle steering in the new GT and Turbo models have since boosted the profile of the purer 997.

3) It’s the pinnacle of the ‘Mezger’ engine
The GT3 RS 4.0-litre was released as the ‘last hurrah’ of the 997 era, and it lived up to its reputation as one of the finest 911s ever built. With a huge 3,996cc engine capacity (you’ll struggle for bigger bores for the flat six than with the RS 4.0) helping to produce nearly 500bhp without a turbocharger in sight, this represents the finest road-going iteration of the famous ‘Mezger’ engine.

Its legacy is protected, too: the 991 GT3 has already ditched the ‘Mezger’ in favour of a reworked DFI Carrera S unit, perhaps an acceptance from Porsche that the engine had reached its maximum capabilities in RS 4.0 guise.

Porsche 911 Sport Classic und Speedster
4) The 997 still gave exclusivity
You can quite easily count over 30 different variants of the 997 before getting into difficulty, but don’t let that put you off the provenance of some variants in the generation. Despite this being the most mass-produced 911 to date, a selection of rare gems were made to keep you on the edge of your seat.

Only 356 Speedsters were made courtesy of the Exclusiv department, for example, while only 250 of the brilliantly nostalgic Sport Classic were produced. Meanwhile, all 918 units of the 997 Turbo S 918 Edition were reserved exclusively for those who had paid a deposit on the new Porsche 918 hypercar. Get your hands on any of these, not to mention a GT2 RS or GT3 RS 4.0 and you’ve got yourself a rare 911 indeed, more exclusive than even the 2.7RS.

5) The RS went turbocharged
Sure, historical geeks will point out the Turbo RSR racer from 1974 to try and usurp my point here, but the 997 GT2 RS represented the first time Porsche had given the Rennsport badge to a road-going turbocharged 911. Moreover, it didn’t disappoint. The 997 GT2 RS is revered as one of the most extreme 911s ever to grace the road, and if you want one for your collection now, you’ll already need to pay considerably more than book price from first release.

6) VTG was introduced
The first generation 997 Turbo was introduced with a new technology: Variable Turbine Geometry. In layman terms this effectively gives the best of both small and large turbochargers thanks to electrically-operated guide vanes in each turbo helping to achieve optimum gas-flow characteristics at all times.

The result is noticeably reduced turbo lag and a wider band of peak torque. This gave turbocharged 997s unrelenting, savage performance right through the rev range, transforming the personality of the Turbo. The technology is still used by Porsche on the 991.

7) The 911 hit 200mph
Twice, in fact. After the 997 GT2 powered on to a confirmed 204mph in 2007, the GT2 RS beat it by 1mph three years later. No other factory 911 has passed the double-ton mark before or since.

To refine my point, I’m not suggesting every 997 model was the best of its kind. Far from it. However, it’s hard to deny that the 997 generation played a vital role in bringing the 911 at large back to form, all the while reaching a pinnacle in blending such blistering performance with modern purity, something no other past, present or future 911 generation is likely to be able to match.

Is the 997 the greatest Porsche 911 generation ever? Have your say in the comments below, or head to our Facebook and Twitter pages to join the debate now.

Comments (20)

  • Jack

    Fully agree with the above points. IMO the 997.2 especially will be coveted given it’s relatively low volumes (post-2008 stock market crash), and it’s significant upgrades to engine, electronics, brakes, and suspension – these were clearly the best of the water-cooled breed to date. The 997 will be the last generation designed/build/sold with Porsche as an independent company – for example, how long until future 911s utilize Audi fasteners ala Lamborghini? My gut, though I don’t have the stats to prove it yet, is the 997 will be the last generation where a significant percentage of the fleet would be manual transmission… PDK is awesome but 30 years from now when every car is electric/hybrid/automatic… these cars will be looked at fondly for their ‘mechanical’ nature… starting with manual transmissions. 997.2 GTS for me please!

  • How many? Jack,
    997 911 2013 turbo s cabriolet built?

  • Why is Porsche hiding the built numbers for 2013-911 turbo s cabriolet?

  • I Found the built numbers 213

  • Being a relatively new 911 owner (2011 Carrera S cab CPO, purchased in December 2013) I must agree. It’s my wife’s DD and she is a purist — 6 speed manual, no buttons or switches on the steering wheel, no mods (other than the clear corners I snuck on without her noticing) … just a pure 911 at its finest. We plan to run it as long as possible, then try to find a 2012 garage queen simply because my wife hates the manual windscreen and 2012’s is automatic. Then we will keep that car likely for the rest of our lives (I’m 52, she’s 49).

  • leonard bullhock

    Agree with the above totally. having owned a 996 and a 997.1 C2S, I now have a 2011 C4S. Night and day performance wise. Handling is magical, as is the new DFI engine and equipped with (a now rare) 6 speed it`s a joy to own and drive.
    My last 2007 C2S suffered from scoring and this model now has the not only better motor but facelift lights, bumpers and dash.
    Total package, A beautiful car.

  • npr

    Half of point 1 was bashing on the 996.
    Do we really need to keep doing this?

  • janon

    I think the 997 interior has aged very badly actually. Its all angular and loaded with now old looking tech. The 996 interior is still by and large an “old school” interior. The argument here seems to be that somehow having no tech ages worse. In reality having lots of tech is much worse because it goes stale in one gen. The 996 interior was also just much simpler and organic looking.

    As for “last mechanical Porsche”… That’s a real stretch when immediately followed with ” well except electronically controlled suspension dampening and electronically variable turbo vanes and electronically distributed torque in the awd diff and…..”

    Thats not to say tech like this is bad as a given, but the 996 is *clearly* the “last mechanical 911” (and even that’s a bit of a stretch)

  • janon

    Its funny because its point one too.

    So the biggest selling point is “doesnt look like a 996” apparently.

    Thats pretty weak differentiation. Personally i like the 996 look, but honestly 99.9% of the planet couldn’t tell a 930 from a 991.

    So take away irrational bias against something as minor as headlight shape and the lead point seems to be “last mechanical 911”. Except that point is caveated with a long list of yet more new complex electronics.

    Given the cost differential this makes the 996 seem a ton better value wise. Esp the turbo or, for the NA, compared against the 997.1 which still suffers IMS issues.

  • Neil Deichman

    I am looking to purchase a 2009 911 Turbo. How do I know if it has the Mezger engine? Does the 997.2 have a Mezger engine or only the 997.1? Please help.

  • Matterafact

    Hate the boring pedestrain look of the 997, I don’t get the hype,
    The 996 turbo and 991 look much more special

  • Matterafact

    Hate the boring pedestrain look of the 997, I don’t get the hype,
    The 996 turbo and 991 look much more special to me.

  • james gordon

    yes I got a 997 turbo Mk 1 manual Metzger engine…My 5th Porsche and a truly amazing car.. Driven carefully returns 30 mpg… Put your foot down and it takes off… Beautiful to drive.. Commands ultimate respect on the road.. Beautiful to behold.. Mines Black… Suits it best in my opinion..

  • Lee Johnson

    I think the Porsche 997 is going to be a classic years from now. Many people still enjoy the look and drivability of the 997, especially compared to the bigger/faster/more tech driven 991. Here is a good comparison page that compares the two – http://www.pcarforsale.com/buying-a-porsche-997-vs-a-porsche-991/

  • Les F

    Just gone over 100,000 miles in my Gen2 3.6 PDK with NO ISSUES. Car looks, feels and runs like it was on day one.

  • Ronald Savenor

    The best is always a matter of opinion.I have an 2008 GT2 and must say I really love it.As visceral as visceral gets!Yes its not RS but Its wonderful ,fast, and rare

  • JM

    Yes I think that the 997 was the best of 911’s. You could find it manual or PDK and a S or GT3 was one of the best N.A. engines. New (all turbos) 991’s not for me. I used to track my ’02 996 at my local PCA (not the one with the egg headlamps) and it handled great but always was with envy looking at those improved 997’s. Great cars!

  • Lavish D

    Love my 997/24S 09
    Takes me away & there everytime w ease, enjoyment & comfort🔀 Merging ✔️

  • Kerem

    Oh what a joy and happiness to own a 997. I always tell my friends that a man shıuld own a Porsche at least once in his life if he can afford it. What better choice than a 997 for its dependabilty, everyday use, afffordablity, looks et etc. Thak you Porsche for the 997 https://uploads.disquscdn.com/images/3d97349d93678b1964ca0ee9389f15298b47be38c3c62b5d97d10cdfc9d5a5b1.jpg

  • MLfree web

    Porsche 911 997 Series 2005–2012 Review